Book Review: Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (Skandar #1)
When I first spotted Skandar and the Unicorn Thief by A.F. Steadman, I felt an irresistible urge to uncover the hype surrounding this new fantasy series—especially considering the grand scale of its worldwide reveal and hefty advance. Could this be the next magical escape for children akin to Harry Potter? I was eager to dive in, hoping to unearth a hidden gem. Alas, what I found was a rather dull imitation, and my excitement swiftly morphed into disappointment.
From the outset, Skandar draws on familiar tropes that echo the iconic Harry Potter formula. We meet Skandar, a blandly crafted hero who’s a half-orphan, bullied and lonely, loaded with a dose of “Chosen One” destiny. He discovers a world filled with unicorns—supposedly ferocious, man-eating unicorns. Instead, we encounter grumpy, magic-wielding horses reminiscent of a more angsty My Little Pony. Early on, I couldn’t help but feel that the narrative was a derivative puzzle, pieced together without a spark of originality.
Steadman’s writing style tries to engage but falls flat; the pacing is sluggish and the world-building disappointingly superficial. The unicorns are almost entirely forgettable, tossed aside after introducing them as these fearsome creatures. The plot centers around a society obsessed with unicorn racing, which could offer a fresh take, but it instead reads like an uninspired gimmick. Imagine a society where producing cosmetic enhancements is the pinnacle of medical achievement—it feels absurd and painfully shallow.
One aspect that was particularly concerning was the moral framework woven into the story. The stakes for Skandar and his peers felt insipid. Here they’re told that failing to excel at racing marks them as Nomads, destined for a life of wandering and shame—a stark reality that feels harsh for young readers. The notion that success is black and white, with no room for failure, is a troubling message to convey.
Character development is another sore point. Skandar and his friends are portrayed as perpetually infantile, with emotions running unchecked. I found it hard to connect with characters who seemed like they were stuck in an immaturity cycle; angst is fine, but without depth or growth, it loses emotional weight.
Despite my dismay, I held a sliver of hope that there would be standout moments or quotes to redeem it. Sadly, I found none that resonated or evoked any feelings beyond the desire to turn the pages faster.
In conclusion, Skandar and the Unicorn Thief might appeal to very young readers or those new to the fantasy genre. However, for anyone seeking depth and originality akin to the likes of J.K. Rowling, this book does not deliver. My hope for this series is that it can grow into something better in its sequels, but as it stands, it felt more like an empty promise than an exciting journey. This experience reminded me of the importance of genuine storytelling—one that resonates with sincerity rather than formula.
Discover more about Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (Skandar #1) on GoodReads >>