Review of My Salty Mary (Mary, #3) by the My Lady Janies
From the moment I cracked open My Salty Mary, the third enchanting installment by the talented My Lady Janies—Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton, and Jodi Meadows—I knew I was in for a treat. A novel that elegantly blends my two favorite genres—romance and fantasy—how could I resist? As a long-time admirer of the authors’ whimsical storytelling and vivid character development, I felt a familiar thrill as I dove into this delightful adventure.
Themes and Characters:
Set in the colorful, lawless world of piracy just after the demise of the infamous Blackbeard, My Salty Mary follows the fierce and spirited Mary Read, who isn’t just any mermaid; she’s a force to be reckoned with. Her love interest, Tobias—or Toby, son of Blackbeard himself—captures the essence of a charming rogue, their chemistry practically crackling off the pages. What truly struck me was how different their romance felt compared to typical best-friends-to-lovers stories. Instead of an obligatory misunderstanding that derails their relationship, their connection develops naturally, with the main tensions stemming from a misconception about Mary’s cousin—before Toby even discovers the truth about their familial ties. This refreshing approach to romance, devoid of unnecessary drama, made my heart swell.
One of the book’s great strengths is its subtle integration of feminism. The narrative showcases Mary’s refusal to be confined by societal norms, and it was thrilling to see the emergence of other female pirates who dared to follow in her footsteps. The underlying message that women can—and should—pursue their ambitions resonates throughout the story, all while maintaining a sense of authenticity. It feels empowering rather than preachy, making it all the more enjoyable.
Writing Style and Pacing:
The authors’ writing is as rich and fluid as the ocean waves surrounding Mary and Toby. Their playful wit and the clever banter between characters kept me hooked, and the pacing felt just right, making it hard to set the book down. I found myself grinning at their interactions, particularly during moments when Toby showed his protective side—not out of jealousy, but pure loyalty to Mary, especially when he confronts Prince Charles. Who wouldn’t appreciate watching a hero stand up for his lady love?
Memorable Highlights:
One standout moment for me was Mary’s determination to win the contest that would crown her Pirate Queen. It’s a privilege not typically afforded to women during that era, and her success here feels like a sweet victory for all aspiring adventurers. The narrative also deftly handles side plots, like Jack (Mary’s cousin) and the puzzling situation surrounding his fiancée—though less central to my attachment to the story, it added layers of intrigue and humor.
Ultimately, I believe My Salty Mary is an absolute gem that beautifully captures the spirit of adventure and romance against the backdrop of a fantastical world. For readers who appreciate strong female leads and aren’t afraid of a little salty sea air, this book is sure to delight.
Whether you’re already a fan of the My Lady Janies or looking to fall in love with a new adventurous tale, I wholeheartedly recommend diving into My Salty Mary. Like me, you might find yourself reflecting on the courage to follow your own dreams—and perhaps even set sail on your own adventure. Happy reading!
Discover more about My Salty Mary (Mary, #3) on GoodReads >>