Review of Fake It Like You Mean It by Megan Murphy
Have you ever picked up a book that resonated so deeply with you, it felt like the author was peering into your soul? That’s exactly what happened when I dove into Fake It Like You Mean It by Megan Murphy. This debut novel caught my attention not just for its quirky premise but also for how it navigates the often-unspoken complexities of life, love, and loss, all while maintaining that delightful balance of humor and heart.
At its core, Fake It Like You Mean It explores the touching story of Elle Monroe, who returns to her hometown to care for her grandmother Lovie, who is battling Alzheimer’s. The unexpected twist? Elle finds grumpy nurse Adam Wheeler sleeping in her bed. What begins as a classic enemies-to-lovers narrative evolves into something far more poignant. Their decision to adopt a “fake couple” persona for Lovie’s sake adds layers to their relationship, transforming it from mere pretense into genuine connection.
Murphy excels in crafting characters that feel like old friends. Elle’s journey as a successful podcaster haunted by her fear of driving and tendency to bolt from complications feels universally relatable. Adam, the dependable caregiver with a heart of gold, challenges her to confront her fears while pushing his own needs aside to care for his sister and her kids. Their banter crackles with tension—who knew a grocery store could be the backdrop for some of the fiercest flirtation?
The supporting cast shines brightly, too. Lovie is not just a plot device; her lucid moments pack an emotional punch that left me breathless. The comic relief provided by Elle’s best friends felt authentic and refreshing, reminding me of the importance of friendship amidst life’s challenges. Murphy’s treatment of Alzheimer’s is both respectful and realistic, capturing the emotional rollercoaster of caregiving without veering into melodrama. The poignant scene where Lovie recognizes Elle after months is a standout, a moment of clarity amid the chaos that illustrates the depth of their bond.
Yet, while the narrative is rich with emotion, I found some pacing issues in the middle sections that felt repetitive. The central conflict around geographical preferences seemed a tad forced given today’s remote work culture. However, these minor setbacks were easily overshadowed by Murphy’s vivid writing. She brings settings to life—from Elle’s Chicago apartment to Lovie’s pink-tiled bathroom—which felt as tangible as the characters themselves.
What truly resonated with me were the subtle messages about self-discovery and the nature of love. I loved how the physical intimacy between Elle and Adam mirrored their emotional evolution. Their journey was about more than just attraction; it was about choosing each other amidst life’s messiness.
For anyone who enjoys contemporary romance with depth, Fake It Like You Mean It is a must-read. Fans of Emily Henry or Christina Lauren will find a kindred spirit in Murphy’s work. Whether you’re drawn in by the humor, the authentic portrayal of caregiving, or the relatable characters navigating complex emotions, this novel has something for everyone.
In the end, Fake It Like You Mean It left me feeling uplifted yet reflective. It beautifully intertwines laughter with heartache, showcasing how life can surprise us with moments of joy and connection even amid trials. I can’t wait to see what Megan Murphy creates next—her talent suggests we’re in for more stories that illuminate the beautiful chaos of love and life.
Discover more about Fake It Like You Mean It on GoodReads >>